The Suburban Times

A community bulletin board for Western Pierce County.

  • Home
  • To Know
  • To Do
  • To Ponder
  • Obituaries
  • Calendar
    • Submit an Event
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • More
    • Share your story
    • Submit an Event
    • Contact

Letter: Alum treatment of Waughop Lake is a big mistake

February 5, 2019 By The Suburban Times

Submitted by Don Russell.

Dear City of Lakewood Council Members, 

In a September 1, 2017 article appearing in The Suburban Times titled “The likely effect of the discontinuance of sewage discharge into Waughop Lake” I indicated that the effect was likely to be an increase in the growth of aquatic plants in the lake.

This prediction was important since nutrient polluted lakes generally exist in one of two stable states.  One stable state is characterized by having turbid water with a predominate population of harmful Cyanobacteria (aka, blue-green algae).  The other stable state is characterized by having clear water with a predominate population of excessive aquatic plants (macrophytes).

Bear in mind that when the Brown & Caldwell study was done in 2014-2015 the lake was being externally nutrient loaded by intermittent discharges of sewage from Pierce College, a situation that had been occurring for many years prior to its discovery in the winter of 2016.  This fact was unbeknownst by those monitoring the water quality during the 2014-2015 study.  Therefore the impact of this discharge on the biological response of the lake was not taken into consideration by those proposing options for the lake’s remediation.

The focus and conclusion of the B&C study was on internal release of phosphorus from bottom sediments and the treatment options that could address this situation.  Removal of the nutrient polluted sediment by dredging was the universally preferred option.  A heavy one shot application of alum to inactivate the phosphorus in both the water column and to a certain depth of sediment (B&C 10 cm and Tetra Tech 22 cm) was proposed as a possible 3 to 5 year technique for preventing harmful Cyanobacteria blooms in Waughop Lake until funding for dredging could be obtained.

With the cessation of intermittent sewage discharge into Waughop Lake its condition is likely to change from a turbid Cyanobacteria infested stable state to a clear water excessive aquatic plant stable state.  Such a transformation will be hastened by application of a lake-wide alum treatment.  Therefore such a heavy one shot lake-wide application of alum at this time is not advisable.

Rather the City should employ the services of either Northwest Aquatic Eco-Systems or AquaTechnex to monitor the lake and each year prescribe and apply the minimal amounts of an herbicide (to control excessive aquatic plant growth), an algaecide (to prevent nuisance filamentous green algae blooms) and a phosphorus inactivation agent (to prevent harmful Cyanobacteria blooms).  This is the method by which all other nutrient polluted lakes in Lakewood are managed to assure their safe beneficial recreational use and is far less expensive that a lake-wide application of alum.

The Brown & Caldwell/Tetra Tech prescription (base upon data from a 2014-2015 study) for a heavy lake-wide alum treatment of the water column and varying depths of bottom sediment was designed to address a turbid Cyanobacteria infested lake (a condition that existed prior to the cessation of Pierce College’s discharge of sewage), not on the emerging transformation of the lake to a clear water excessive aquatic plant growth state.

The question arises as to why should you seriously consider what I have stated above. From 2009 through 2016 I was the volunteer Waughop Lake water quality monitor for the Tacoma Pierce County Health Department (2009-2013) and the City of Lakewood (2014-2016).  Tom McClellan has been the volunteer Waughop Lake water quality monitor for the City of Lakewood for 2017-2018.  It is time for you to seriously consider the merits of what we both have to say about the proper and cost effective management of Waughop Lake’s water quality.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Related

Comments

  1. Fred Block says

    February 6, 2019 at 1:31 pm

    Mr. Russell’s comments make sense. If the consultant’s studies were performed without knowledge of the ongoing sewage discharges coming from the college, it is reasonable to doubt the conclusions reached in those studies.

Top Stories

  • Permit filed for 22-unit multifamily development in Lakewood
    Permit filed for 22-unit multifamily development in Lakewood
  • Obituary Notices - March 3, 2021
    Obituary Notices - March 3, 2021
  • Fort Steilacoom Park All-Access Playground Update
    Fort Steilacoom Park All-Access Playground Update
  • Commerce Street closed between I-705 and Theater District Station for track installation
    Commerce Street closed between I-705 and Theater District Station for track installation
  • Reliving the Magnitude 6.8 Nisqually Earthquake 20 Years Later
    Reliving the Magnitude 6.8 Nisqually Earthquake 20 Years Later

Become a better informed citizen.

Join over 30,000 readers each month and get real-local news and information direct to your inbox, Monday-Saturday.


Recent Comments

  • R.Lopaka on Oakbrook Elementary turning 50 in 2021
  • Shelley Hull on Reliving the Magnitude 6.8 Nisqually Earthquake 20 Years Later
  • Susanne Bacon on Reliving the Magnitude 6.8 Nisqually Earthquake 20 Years Later
  • Jackie LOWNIE on Reliving the Magnitude 6.8 Nisqually Earthquake 20 Years Later
  • Don Doman on Kimball achieves prestigious Top of the Table qualification

Contact Us

The Suburban Times
P.O. Box 39099
Lakewood, WA 98496

Ben Sclair, Publisher
253-312-1804

Stephen Neufeld, Marketing Executive
stephen@thesubtimes.com

Copyright © 2021 The Suburban Times • Log in • Privacy Policy

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.